In the world of nostalgic breakfast foods, three categories stand out as the most loved and most missed: discontinued breakfast cereals, discontinued Eggo flavors, and discontinued Pop-Tart flavors. Each of these iconic breakfast staples holds a special place in the hearts of people with a tendency toward food nostalgia.
When it comes to Pop-Tarts, they’ve been a breakfast and snack-time favorite since they were introduced in 1964. Since then Kellogg’s has launched dozens of unique and sometimes bizarre flavors, many of which have since been discontinued. Flavors disappear for a variety of reasons, including poor sales, limited-time promotions, or simply to make room for new releases. Some flavors leave quietly, while others have fans rallying online for their return, including a bunch of Change.org petitions. Below, we take a look at some of the most iconic and fan-favorite discontinued Pop-Tart flavors that continue to live rent-free in our memories.
1. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pop-Tarts
One of the most beloved flavors, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pop-Tarts captured the hearts of snackers everywhere. This indulgent flavor mimicked the taste of raw cookie dough, a flavor profile that has remained popular in desserts for years. Fans were heartbroken when this flavor was discontinued, and petitions to bring it back still circulate online including this change.org petition with almost 2,000 signatures.
2. Cinnamon Roll Pop-Tarts
Cinnamon Roll Pop-Tarts had the distinct warm and gooey taste of fresh cinnamon rolls. The filling had a delightful blend of cinnamon and sugar, and the soft pastry was topped with a sweet icing drizzle. While similar to the Cinnamon Sugar Pop-Tart, this one had a unique, creamy flavor that fans continue to miss.
3. Mint Chocolate Chip Pop-Tarts
Released in 2006, Mint Chocolate Chip Pop-Tarts had a refreshing, dessert-like taste. Kellogg’s even suggested freezing them to create a “Pop-Tartsicle” experience. This flavor was discontinued after only a short run, but its uniqueness has left a lasting impression.
4. Strawberry Cheese Danish Pop-Tarts
Strawberry Cheese Danish Pop-Tarts combined a fruity strawberry filling with a smooth cream cheese layer, creating a rich and satisfying breakfast option. Launched in 2007, this flavor only lasted a couple of years, but its unique taste and bakery-inspired concept earned it a loyal following.
5. French Toast Pop-Tarts
Introduced in 2004, French Toast Pop-Tarts were the ultimate breakfast-inspired flavor. They featured a sweet maple syrup filling and a cinnamon sugar-coated crust, delivering a true taste of French toast. Unlike many Pop-Tart flavors, this one had no frosting on top, making it stand out from the pack.
6. Rainbow Cookie Sandwich Pop-Tarts
This eye-catching flavor featured rainbow sprinkles on a soft, sugar-cookie-inspired crust. Inside, the filling was sweet, colorful, and reminiscent of a classic rainbow cookie sandwich. It was a visual treat as much as it was a flavorful one, and fans continue to reminisce about it online.
7. Frosted Grape Pop-Tarts
Grape was one of the original Pop-Tart flavors in 1967, but the frosted version was a modern revival. This flavor had a sweet and tangy grape filling, much like grape-flavored candies. Discontinued in 2017, Frosted Grape Pop-Tarts still has a fan base advocating for its return.
8. Blueberry Muffin Pop-Tarts
As part of the “muffin-inspired” flavor series, Blueberry Muffin Pop-Tarts aimed to recreate the taste of a freshly baked blueberry muffin. With a rich, fruity filling and a sugary crumb-like topping, it was a breakfast dream come true—until it vanished from shelves.
9. Red Velvet Pop-Tarts
Red Velvet has had its moment as a trendy dessert flavor, and Pop-Tarts jumped on the bandwagon with this offering. The filling had that distinct, slightly cocoa-like red velvet flavor, while the frosting mimicked cream cheese icing. Originally a limited-time flavor, it was so popular that fans begged for it to be made permanent.
10. PB&J Pop-Tarts
Who doesn’t love a classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich? PB&J Pop-Tarts captured that nostalgic flavor with a peanut butter and fruity jelly filling. These Pop-Tarts had a short run but remain one of the most requested discontinued flavors to this day.
11. Froot Loop Pop-Tarts
A playful collaboration between Kellogg’s two iconic brands, Froot Loop Pop-Tarts were colorful, quirky, and full of fruity flavor. While these were only available for a limited time, they’re still fondly remembered.
12. Banana Creme Pie Pop-Tarts
Banana Creme Pie Pop-Tarts offered a rich, custard-like filling with the tropical flavor of bananas. While not as widely loved as other flavors, its fans remain vocal, calling for its return to store shelves.
13. Frosted Apple Pop-Tarts
Apple Pop-Tarts were part of the original flavor lineup in 1967. The frosted version had a spiced apple filling reminiscent of apple pie, and its distinct autumnal taste made it a seasonal favorite. Discontinued in the 2000s, it’s still remembered fondly by nostalgic fans.
14. Chocolate Vanilla Creme Pop-Tarts
A combination of chocolate crust and creamy vanilla filling made this a must-try flavor. This pairing of two classic flavors gave Pop-Tart lovers a best-of-both-worlds experience. It’s been known to return as an exclusive flavor from time to time.
15. Eggo Waffle Pop-Tarts
Breakfast mashups don’t get better than this. Eggo Waffle Pop-Tarts combined the sweet, buttery flavor of an Eggo waffle with a maple syrup-inspired filling. Fans of Eggo waffles and Pop-Tarts alike still hope for its return.
16. Chocolate Banana Split Pop-Tarts
Chocolate Banana Split Pop-Tarts featured a banana-flavored filling with hints of chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla to replicate the flavors of a classic banana split. Introduced in 2009, these colorful Pop-Tarts had a playful design and a flavor that tasted more like candy than breakfast. The combination of banana and chocolate made them stand out, but despite their uniqueness, they were ultimately discontinued, leaving fans to reminisce about this sweet treat.
17. Root Beer Pop-Tarts
Root Beer Pop-Tarts were as unique as they come, bringing the spicy, sweet flavor of root beer to a toaster pastry. This limited-time flavor had a polarizing reception, as some loved the bold, soda-inspired taste, while others found it too unconventional for a breakfast treat. Regardless, Root Beer Pop-Tarts became a cult favorite, and fans have since expressed their desire for its return.
18. Hot Chocolate Pop-Tarts
Nothing warms you up on a cold day like hot chocolate, and Kellogg’s transformed this experience into a Pop-Tart. Released in 2007, Hot Chocolate Pop-Tarts featured a chocolate crust, marshmallow swirl frosting, and gooey chocolate filling, making it a winter favorite. The comforting flavor of hot cocoa in Pop-Tart form was a seasonal delight that fans still miss.
19. Frosted Lava Berry Explosion Pop-Tarts
A tie-in with Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, Frosted Lava Berry Explosion had a wild berry-flavored filling and vibrant, lava-inspired frosting. The bright colors and playful design made it a collector’s item, especially among Star Wars enthusiasts. Its limited-time nature made it a rare gem in the Pop-Tart lineup, and its flashy appearance and fruity taste are still remembered fondly.
20. Peach Cobbler Pop-Tarts
Last, but by no means the least, are the Peach Cobbler Pop-Tarts. They were a delightful nod to the classic southern dessert. With a sweet peach-flavored filling and a spiced cinnamon glaze, these Pop-Tarts captured the comforting, home-baked taste of fresh peach cobbler. The outer crust had a golden, flaky texture reminiscent of a pie crust, adding to its authenticity. Fans adored the rich, fruity flavor and unique twist on a classic comfort food.
Unfortunately, Peach Cobbler Pop-Tarts were only available for a limited time, and their disappearance left snackers craving more. To this day, nostalgic fans still petition for its return, hoping to enjoy that sweet and spiced perfection once again.
Hungry for more discontinued flavors?
If you’re a fan of discontinued flavors, you’re not alone. I’m working my way through all the discontinued foods and drinks that I feel nostalgic for (and know others do too).
